Rachel’s Ultimate Crab Dip

16 oz blue crab claw meat
8 oz cream cheese, at room temperature
3/4 cup sour cream
3/4 cup sharp cheddar
2 1/2 tablespoons mayonnaise
1 1/2 tablespoons Old Bay
1/2 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
1/4 teaspoon celery seed
1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
1/4 teaspoon mustard powder
1 shallot, minced

Preheat oven to 350. Mix all ingredients EXCEPT the cheddar cheese until they are evenly distributed. Or, if you are like me and you hate mincing yet don’t want any chunky shallot bits in the final dip or want make sure the ingredients are fully incorporated, place all of the ingredients EXCEPT the cheddar and crab in a food processor and pulse until smooth. Then stir in the crab.

Spread into a 8×8 inch baking dish. Sprinkle with the cheese in an even layer. For bonus points, shake a bit of Old Bay on top of the cheese.

Bake for about 15 minutes or until the cheese is melted and bubbling.

Serve warm with crackers, pretzels, bread wedges, or plain Utz chips. Cover and refrigerate any leftovers. Bake @ 350 for 10 minutes or so to reheat. I don’t recommend microwaving.

Note: For this recipe, quality reduced fat sour cream and cream cheese will work just fine.

My thoughts:

Crab dip is serious business here in Baltimore. We are a people who like our (blue) crabs and our cheesy dips. Growing up, my family didn’t do much in the way of entertaining and well, crab is pricey so we didn’t make it but I loved having friends whose families would make it for holiday parties and such. Of course, it has been on the menu of nearly every locally owned restaurant and pub at some point or another. I think if it doesn’t make an appearance on the menu at least once, your food permit gets yanked.

Anyway, for the perfect crab dip you need, crab, some sort of combination of cream cheese, mayonnaise (or occasionally straight mayonnaise, no cream cheese), shredded cheese and lots of Old Bay. Beyond that I’ve had versions with garlic or garlic powder, onions or shallots, mustard, Parmesan cheese, and crab meat of every variety of from lump to backfin. I like to use claw because it has a flavor that is stronger than lump meat (but still sweet and not “fishy”) and has a good mix of big chunks and smaller bits of crab. I like how the crab is distributed in the dip if you use claw or even backfin, with jumbo or regular lump you end up occasionally getting a bite that is entirely crab free. Not a problem with the claw.

When I set out to make the ultimate crab dip I had some parameters in mind. It had to be thick, creamy but not too mayonnaise-y, and spiced but not overpoweringly spicy. I am a sour cream addict so I always have to add that to my dips. I think the slight tang keeps the dip from tasting too rich or cloying. The trick is not to use too much or the crab will be spread too thin. You want a dip that is thick with crab meat. I like the crab flavor to be the star so I only put a thin layer of cheddar on the top (not mixed in as I’ve seen in some recipes) and just enough spices to accent the crab flavor, not overwhelm it. I always use extra sharp cheddar but a mix of cheddar and Monterey Jack (in a 2:1 ratio) is a good variation.

Crab dip is so popular here in Baltimore that it actually has spawned a spin off appetizer, the crab pretzel, which isn’t quite as common but perhaps it should be, it is sort of a twist on the dip in the bread bowl fad of 30 years ago and is oddly satisfying.


  1. dave -nibbleanibble

    The dip is making my mouth watery. Love crab!

  2. Fried Wontons For You

    Many of the crab recipe I've tried either had too much mayonnaise or too much cheese and not enough flavor. This looks like a very good quick and tasteful dip to whip up. Really like the addition of the Worcestershire sauce. Is there any substitute for celery seed?

  3. LOVE crab dip, even my 8 year old eats it. I might be the hero of the weekend if I try this one!

  4. I will definitely try this! Love that crab dip and the name of your blog is pretty great also!

  5. Fried Wonton-
    There really isn't a substitute for celery seed but it isn't completely necessary as there is celery seed in the Old Bay. You could leave it out if you wanted.

  6. Oh NOM. I definitely bookmarked this because I *might* be going back to seafood in November (celebrate 5 years of vegetarianism by quitting, ha) and it's too good to miss out on.

  7. I COMPLETELY agree about the claw meat for crab dip. I always felt that lump, while pretty and impressive, cannot stand up the assertive flavors of cream cheese etc. Just make sure that you buy hand picked claw as opposed to machine picked which is meant for soup as it is quite salty due to the salt added during processing.

    I'm a purist who skips the cheddar, but plenty of people here in B-More do like it that way.

  8. o….m…..g!!!!! this is so delicious! i added artichoke hearts to your recipe. THUMBS UP!!

  9. hmm, crab dip isn't such serious business around here, but these sounds really good.

  10. Is it just me, or is crab really expensive? Because of this recipe, I have been looking for crabmeat, but it's so expensive! Looks like I may have to wait on this dip then until I go halfsies on it with someone else! :-/

  11. Margaret,
    Fresh crab is always an expensive ingredient. Claw meat is one of the more affordable kinds (lump, jumbo lump are much more expensive) which is one of the reasons it is a good fit for a dip. I suggest you do what I do and watch the circulars and buy it when it goes on sale.

  12. I added a few cloves of garlic and put the crab dip on a pizza crust… YUM!!!

  13. @Margaret

    I'm not sure what area you live in, but if you have a Trader Joes in your area you can get 1lb cans of claw crab meat in the meat/seafood refrigerated section for a decent price (and it actually tastes pretty good!). The plus side is that this makes a large amount of dip so it feeds a crowd. Or if you can get crab by the 1/2Lb, half the recipe and it will still be great for 4-6 people.